Why do some coins have rough, bumpy edges while others are perfectly smooth?

Some coins have ridged edges because of a centuries-old crime called coin clipping. When coins were made of real silver and gold, people shaved metal off the rims, and ridged, or "milled," edges made any tampering obvious. Coins made of cheap metal were never worth clipping, so many of them stayed smooth. Today the ridges mostly survive as tradition, as a defense against counterfeiting, and as a way to tell coins apart by touch.
In the US, run your thumb along a penny or a nickel and the edge is smooth; do the same with a dime or a quarter and you feel a row of tiny ridges, known as reeding.
What was coin clipping?
Coin clipping was the practice of shaving small amounts of precious metal off the edges of gold and silver coins. Back when a coin's value rested on the metal it contained, a clipper could pass the lighter coin on at full face value and melt down or sell the shavings.
The old hand-hammered coins made this easy. The Perth Mint explains that the irregular, rimless coins of late 17th-century England were easy to clip without detection, and that high prices for silver bullion in continental Europe made the temptation hard to resist.
How did milled edges stop clipping?
Milled edges made a clipped coin instantly recognizable. If a coin is perfectly round and its rim carries a pattern of grooves or lettering, shaving off even a little metal removes part of that pattern, so anyone can feel or see that the coin has been tampered with.
England already had machine-made coins with protected edges before the crisis peaked. Silver coins struck by machine at the Royal Mint after 1662 had engraved, decorated and milled edges, but the older hammered coins, many of them clipped and worn, were still circulating alongside them, according to Wikipedia's account of the Great Recoinage of 1696.
Did Isaac Newton invent ridged coin edges?
No, though he is often credited with them. Newton became Warden of the Royal Mint in 1696, in the middle of the Great Recoinage, which recalled the clipped and worn silver and replaced it with round, machine-made coins with milled edges. The Perth Mint says that when the recoinage was complete in 1698 it "stopped clippers in their tracks," and that Newton oversaw it efficiently.
The Royal Mint Museum is more cautious about his role. It credits Newton's able administration for the recoinage's success, but notes he was not an innovator and left the Mint much as he found it. He spent much of his time there pursuing clippers and counterfeiters.
Why are some coins smooth?
Because low-value coins made of base metal were never worth clipping. Shaving a sliver of copper off a penny wouldn't pay for the effort, so there was no reason to protect the edge.
In the US the pattern still follows the old metals. Dimes and quarters were silver coins until the Coinage Act of 1965 removed silver from them, and they kept their reeded edges afterward. The low-value penny and nickel have smooth edges.
Why do modern coins still have ridges?
Mostly tradition, plus two practical benefits. Clipping a modern coin made of base metal is largely pointless, but the Perth Mint notes that milled edges remain a useful deterrent to counterfeiters, and that edge patterns help blind people tell denominations apart. Australia's coins are an example: the two-dollar coin has a mostly smooth rim with small milled sections, while the one-dollar coin has a mostly milled rim with small smooth sections.
So the ridges on a quarter are a leftover from the age of silver coins, kept because they still do a useful job.
The wider the reasons behind everyday objects picture: Notebook Margins and Rats: Myth or History? and Why Winter Hats Have Pom-Poms: Myth vs. Fact.


